Knowledge is Power, John Henry

Knowledge is Power: how magic, the government, and an apocalyptic vision inspired Francis Bacon to create modern science by John Henry.  I picked this up at a book sale when I was reading a book about the creation of the term "scientist."  I have read Bacon's New Atlantis, so I was aware that he had a Utopian concept of how the world should operate in the pursuit of science and I was also aware that Bacon is credited with the creation of the Scientific Method.

Started:  1/14/2017
Completed: 1/23/2017
Recommendation: Recommended
Recommended By:  Nobody

Review:

The view of magic held at the time of Francis Bacon is not at all what I expected and is the single largest thing that I take away from this book.  I have found overlap between the concept of magic at this time and the concepts behind current homeopathy and it is interesting to me that magicians were far more into experimentation than natural philosophers.  It makes sense, given the chemical manipulations behind alchemy, but I just never looked at magic that way.  Bacon himself (independent of his ideas) has held little interest for me, but I'm glad to understand him better and to realize that he was not necessarily a man of good character himself.

It was no surprise to me that Bacon saw his pursuit of science as part of his understanding of God and that perspective just makes so much more sense for a man of his time than a secret atheist.

The text is quite dry and the presentation of material lacks the value of a compelling narrative.  Having said that, it feels like a series of lectures from a very good professor.  So, while it may take some struggle to fight through the book, the time is well spent as the material itself is so interesting.

The Tipping Point, Malcolm Gladwell

The Tipping Point:  How Little Things Can Make a Big Difference by Malcolm Gladwell is a book I picked up when I saw the trailer from Fortune magazine "A fascinating book that makes you see the world in a different way."

Started:  1/9/2017

Completed:  1/10/2017

Recommendation: Not a strong recommendation

Recommended By: Nobody

Review:

I was anticipating something like Freakonomics (see my post http://reademall.blogspot.com/2014/09/super-freakonomics-levitt-and-dubner.html), but got something much more subtle and dated.  It looks like this book which was written in 2000 was far more subject to more current research than one might thing.  The "law of 7" and the "rule of 150" are both rather well established and it is mildly interesting to see how they play a role in the idea of something suddenly becoming popular or being wildly successful.  The references to the broken window theory and its association with crime have been pretty solidly disproven.

In addition, the whole concept of Paul Revere's ride upon which several examples in the book hinge have also been disproven.  Gladwell suggests that Revere was more successful than Dawes, but this assertion is only in the Longfellow poem.  Moreover, there was likely a third rider involved as well.  Beyond that, there were a slew of messages to get everyone ready for the British...so many, in fact, that Revere's contributions were likely just a drop in the bucket (still heroic and immortalized by Longfellow).  This seriously dilutes the example.

These are just the examples for which I know the back story.

Having said that, the concepts presented in the book are interesting and worth the read, it's just that the examples are not compelling.

In The Heart of The Sea, Nathaniel Philbrick

In the Heart of the Sea:  The Tragedy of the Whaleship Essex by Nathaniel Philbrick received the National Book Award in 2000 and was subsequently made into an unsuccessful moving by Ron Howard.  I listened to the unabridged audio version which tells the true story behind Moby Dick.

Started: 12/9/2016
Completed: 1/9/2017
Recommendation: Recommended, but you need a strong stomach
Recommended By: Nobody

Words for which I sought help:

consanguinity -- kinship; close relationship or close connection

Review:

The book starts at the end with the survivors being found by another whaleship.  That is as good a place as any.  There is a fair amount of time spent talking in graphic detail about the process of killing and recovering the oil from a whale.  It is nauseating.  This is a recurring theme, however, throughout the book and seems to pop up again just when you might have thought you'd been through it enough.  One would think it would pale in comparison to the cannibalism, but it does not.

This is a well written book that is difficult to assimilate.  The story is gripping and the characters are relatively interesting.  There are tons of interesting facts about whaling I never considered (like a boat only had around 20 people on it) and the implications of the hunting on the family (whale hunting took about 3 years per voyage).  The chronicling of bad judgement and bad mistakes (as well as bad luck) is enough to make you think that the survivors must have used up their bad luck in this one event.  Of course, they didn't and the whole story is more interesting for it.

Are we Rome?, Cullen Murphy

Are we Rome?: the fall of an Empire and the fate of America by Cullen Murphy is a book that went from shelf to basket the instant I saw it.  It is a thesis I have long held and I bought it with a friend during lunch at work.  It has sat on my "to read" pile for over 5 years.

Started: 12/8/2016

Completed: 1/14/2017

Recommendation: Recommended

Recommended By:  Nobody

Words for which I sought help:

abstemious -- not eating or drinking too much

languid arrogance -- a slow, calm, almost relaxed disdain for others; a torpid condescension as though the very effort of looking down upon others was hardly worth the effort, so little was exerted.  The phrase is usually associated with royalty glancing down at the clanging mob from a throne.  I kind of imagined this phrase being associated with Marie Antionette or, perhaps, William Blackstone.

limpet -- a marine mollusk with a shallow conical shell and a broad muscular foot, noted for the way it clings tightly to rocks

parlous -- full of danger or risk

precocity--characterized by early development

solipsism -- a philosophical belief that your own existence is all that is real or can be known

sybaritic -- voluptuous or sensualist

Review:

The author is neither an apologist for America nor Rome.  His thesis is that while there are neither sure linkages there are sufficient similarities and differences to give us pause.  The author takes a brave shot at suggesting a path forward at the end of the book and it has merit.  His overall conclusion, however, is that Americans should be able to overcome our own obstacles by doing what we do best--be American.  It is clear, however, that this advice is given without the election of Trump in mind.

Knight Life, Peter David

Knight Life by Peter David is the classic tale of Arthur, King of the Britons.  This was Peter David's first book and predated all his work in comics.  I have a very hard time passing up a book on Arthur.

Started: 12/12/2016

Completed: 1/1/2017

Recommendation: Mild Recommendation

Recommended By:  Nobody

Words for which I sought help:

avuncular -- suggestive of an uncle especially of kindliness and geniality

sartorial -- of or related to clothing

tonsorial -- of or related to a barber

Review:

It was a bit hard to read this story of a business man out of no where winning an election.  That it was the good King Arthur who "spoke without a script" was only mildly helpful.  Certainly, Mr. David never intended that his satire on the story of King Arthur would ever be manifested.  That this, his first novel, became a series is not shocking, but it is rather difficult for me to imagine reading another.  This one was funny, but a lot of the humor came from the juxtaposition of King Arthur in modern New York.  The next book in the series would have a hard time, in my opinion, maintaining this charm, so I don't plan to read another in the series.  For those who would like a new take on the classic tale, this is that.