Showing posts with label Jennifer Saint. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jennifer Saint. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 7, 2023

Atalanta, Jennifer Saint

 

Atalanta by Jennifer Saint

Started: 5/31/2023
Completed: 6/6/2023
Recommendation: Mild recommendation
Recommended By: Nobody, I enjoyed Elektra

Review:

Saint elaborates on this minor character in Greek mythos and I kept wondering how she was going to end the story as the Greek myths are far from clear.  The ending is abrupt and I guess that was to be expected.  Saint does a good job of drawing together the pieces of the myth and putting a believable story around it largely by retelling the story of the Golden Fleece.  This part is really well done, but the extensive effort to maximize opportunities to emphasize Atalanta's feminist positions (which are all quite reasonable) sort of becomes repetitive (others might argue celebratory).  This happens to the point where Atalanta leaves the role of feminine possibility for the age and fully becomes myth.  I think it sucks the way women have been and continue to be treated, but this book makes Atalanta a mythical hero whose achievements cannot be achieved by normal mortals.  This is true in areas (like foot racing) where a hero should have this distinction and also in others (like claiming a kill) where a woman's position would be supported by no man of the era (no matter how inclined to fancy the woman).  I just feel like it would have been nice for her actions to be heroic, but for her to have qualities that are common to every woman making her a role model and not simply a myth.  I dunno, certainly not my area of specialty and maybe my thinking is out of line with what is appropriate and reasonable

Wednesday, November 30, 2022

Elektra, Jennifer Saint

 

Elektra by Jennifer Saint

Started: 11/27/2022
Completed: 11/30/2022
Recommendation: Highly Recommended
Recommended By: Nobody

Review:

I have never really studied the Iliad.  I knew it only in broad swipes and this book fills in the details in a far less ponderous manner than the original Greek.  I knew nothing of Elektra.  For that matter, I did not realize that Helen was sister to Agamemnon's wife!  This book seems to follow the plot as outlined in Aeschylus' play Agamemnon though I wouldn't know as I have not read the play.   The changing perspectives (there were several narrators) was nice in what is truly a difficult story to wrap one's head around (surely easier in Ancient Greece for those already familiar with the broad strokes).  I think this is kind of like the way that Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead relies upon a certain understanding of Macbeth.  I enjoyed the retelling and, therefore, recommend it for those with a passing familiarity with the Iliad.  I did not find the characters to be particularly deep and the only development seemed to be with Clytemnestra, whose fatal flaw seems to be love of her children(?).