Showing posts with label Matthew Desmond. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Matthew Desmond. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 5, 2023

Poverty, By America, Matthew Desmond

 

Poverty, By America by Matthew Desmond.  Thought he wrote an excellent book in Evicted.

Started: 4/3/2023
Completed: 4/4/2023
Recommendation: Highly Recommended
Recommended By: Nobody

Review:

This book steps from documenting a problem to identifying actions to resolve the problem.  There is no doubt that Desmond works to reduce human suffering.  He provides suggestions to resolve that suffering.  He is committed to that work.  He accurately identifies that the cost to implement his suggestions is neither trivial nor huge.  He laments that this work has not already begun.  He is right on all counts.  His efforts to tie poverty to other issues, like climate change are both self-defeating (companies advertise their climate supporting efforts without really making any changes and polish the turd in doing so) and not answers (he has identified so many issues that it is very difficult to support any company).  The problem is that poverty is pervasive.  I think his stronger argument, simply that it should not exist, is much stronger then the whack-a-mole approach of buycotting.  Perhaps his strongest argument is to remind us that we live in plenty and politicians who talk about diminishing resources in areas like food, shelter, and clothing are extremists at best and liars at worst.

Friday, February 21, 2020

Evicted, Matthew Desmond

Evicted:  Poverty and Profit in The American City by Matthew Desmond is a book that my wife saw and thought we should both understand how eviction is effecting America.

Started: 2/18/2020
Completed: 2/21/2020
Recommendation: Highly recommended
Recommended By: My wife

Review:

This is a hard book to read, pretty much nothing but sad.  Eviction is a horror.

These are individual stories.  This is a tiny fraction of the actual evictions that took place over the period the book covers.  Despite that, each story is characteristic of the broader issue and carries its own nuances.  These individual stories stand on their own, but as a spotlight illuminating a small subset, they give character to the whole problem.

Carrying the knowledge of what happens is hard.  It is our responsibility, however, as Americans.  Utah's Housing First seems like a good answer.  As important as healthcare, and maybe more important, housing issues need to be solved.  A cycle of evictions perpetuates a problem that could be stopped.